How to Start your IRA and why Roth is better

Posted on Posted in Personal Finance

First of all, if the company you work for offers a match with their 401k or other retirement plan, do that first! My company offers a dollar-for-dollar match for the first 5% of my salary that I invest. That means I double my money, making instant 100% returns on top of what I would make in the financial markets. Who doesn’t want Free Money!?

After that, pay off all your high-interest debt!

Then fund your Individual Retirement Account(IRA).

Disclaimer: There is no one-size fits all when it comes to financial advice, but I personally hate when people say “It depends…” and proceed to give an answer that does not add value. To avoid this, I’ve laid out some generalized advice that will be helpful to the majority of millennials who’ve recently entered the work force and want to invest their money.  


How 90% of Millenials should start their IRA
  1. Go to .
  2. Open a Roth-IRA.
  3. Put in at least $1000 via bank deposit.
  4. Purchase your target year retirement stock(For me that would be VFFVX 2055).
  5. Set up automatic deposits from your bank account so that you max out the $5,500 that you are eligible to put in for the year. ($450/month).
  6. Once you have $3000+ in your account, I strongly suggest looking at the other low-expense index funds Vanguard has to offer. (Ex. VFINX Vanguards S&P 500 Index Fund).
  7. Once you have $10,000+ in your account, consider moving funds to an even lower-expense Vanguard Admiral Fund.


Why save/invest in an IRA anyway?

40 years ago, if you had put away just $1000 into the Stock Market under a S&P 500 Fund(Tracks the financials for the top 500 companies in America) it would have grown to $23,500!

These days, a savings account from the big banks (PNC, Wells Fargo, BoA, Chase, etc.) will give you .03% interest over the year. So if you stash $50,000 in your savings, at the end of the year you get $15. Transpose this with keeping your money in the market through an IRA and get the stock market average return of 7%, and that $50,000, makes you $3,500.

Unless your a day trader who hopes to make their income off of trading, I recommend investing through an IRA rather than a standard brokerage account. When I first started investing I opened a regular brokerage account through Scottrade. This was a mistake. I didn’t need the money, I just wanted to invest it so it would grow for the future. So basically I was using taxed money that I again paid taxes on when it would grow… bad idea!

An IRA is a tax-advantaged savings account that allows you to forego one of these taxes. Essentially, you pay half the taxes. That can be quite a big deal. If you don’t need to immediately access the gains on your investments, I definitely recommend investing through an IRA rather than a standard brokerage account. You can pick the same stocks/funds with an IRA as with a standard brokerage account, and can even use a self-directed IRA to purchase things like rental properties.


What is the difference between ROTH and TRADITIONAL IRAs?

The difference between these two types of IRAs is primarily when the money put into the accounts get taxed.

Roth: You put money in after you paid taxes on it. But it is tax-free to withdraw.

Traditional: You put in tax-free money, but pay taxes when you withdraw it.

From a purely mathematical perspective these two options are the same. Let’s say you are in the 20% tax bracket when you put in your money ($1000) and when you withdraw your money 5 years later. Let’s also say that the money you put in went up 10% a year. Here’s how it goes:

Roth: $800 -> $880 ->  $968 -> $1065 -> $1171 = $1171(Money you withdraw)

Traditional: $1000 -> $1100 -> $1210 -> $1331 -> $1464 = $1171(Money you withdraw after 20% tax)

Although it may initially appear that neither option is better, there are several things to consider when deciding which IRA is best:

  • Are they going to be richer and in a higher tax bracket when you retire(10%, 15%, 25%, 39.6%)?
  • Are they in a high or low tax bracket right now?
  • Will you potentially need access to the money prior to retirement?
  • Additionally, there are income limits for the Roth, so you may be forced to go Traditional. But, there are stricter income limits for the Traditional if your work offers a 401k or other retirement plan. I’ll discuss this later.


So why is the ROTH IRA better?

The main reason that I think a Roth IRA is better than a traditional IRA is that you can withdraw your contributions penalty-free from your Roth IRA at any point. For a more in-depth look at IRA withdrawal rules, check out this link from vanguard .

Let’s say you put in $5000 yesterday, and today you find an incredible real estate property that requires a $5000 down payment. You can withdraw that money penalty-free.

Tip: Even though withdrawals are penalty free, you are only able to contribute $5,500 a year. You don’t necessarily want to penalize yourself by withdrawing the $20k which took you 4 years to store. However, the IRS will allow you to return any amount you withdraw as long as you do it within 60 days. Keep in mind this is considered a roll-over and can only be done once every 12 months.

One of the few reasons why you might want to go against this advice is if you plan to retire early and take advantage of the Roth Conversion Ladder. (If you are planning to retire early, you are probably financially savvy enough to heed your own advice).

Some other reasons Roth is better:

  • You are limited to only putting $5500/year into an IRA, but $5,500 a year after taxes is like condensed money and worth a lot more than before-tax dollars. So you are effectively able to contribute more.
  • If your work offers you a retirement plan(401k/403b), you are restricted from contributing to a traditional IRA if your Modified Adjusted Gross Income is over $62k[single]/$99k[married]. As opposed to Roth-IRA limitation starting at $118k[single]/$186k[married].
  • You as a FamVestor reader will likely be making more money and be in a higher tax bracket in the future.


Should I save enough for an emergency fund first?

I hear many excuses for why people have not started their IRA yet. Many financial advisers suggest that people create an emergency fund before making investments. But, because of the flexibility of the Roth IRA, I recommend (contrary to most advisers) that people use their Roth IRA as an emergency fund. I think it prudent to keep some money ($1k-$3k) in your savings, but I don’t agree that you need to stash away 6 months of expenses in a savings account before even considering depositing money into an IRA.

Rather than sticking your money in a .03% return savings account, you have some real potential to get a good (>7%) return that will help you save towards retirement. And, if you do ever need those funds in an emergency, you will be able to pull out all your contributions exactly as if the money were in a savings account, albeit with maybe a week’s transaction delay.

It’s a win-win. You have access to the funds if you ever need them, and they gain interest in the meantime. It’s actually more likely that these funds will remain untouched, since you probably won’t check the balance as frequently as you might a savings account.

The caveat here and the reason most financial planners do not recommend this strategy is the element of risk it adds. What happens if the market crashes and you need that money?

Example: You put in $5500 and the markets drop 30%, so now you only have $3850 in the Roth IRA, but you get into a car accident and you need those funds right away. Because its an emergency and you cannot wait for the money to grow back to $5500+, you effectively lose 30% of that money and you only have the $3850 to use towards your emergency.

My recommendation: Take a look at the historic average, notice your own tendencies, and your risk tolerance – then decide if this strategy is right for you.

So start auto-depositing to max out your Roth IRA today! It will take $458/month to max it out if you start in January. Set it and forget it. If you do ever need it, you have no worries, because you can always pull that money back if necessary. So what do you have to lose? Start right now! There are no excuses!


Case Study: My Personal Investing Story
My Portfolio as of 3/24/17; Stocks Crossed Out in Red have been Sold

I opened a Scottrade brokerage account  and bought my first stock in 2011. I started getting the $25k Smart Scholarship stipend at that time and thought it would be good to start learning about investing. After no research, on 10/20/2011 I bought 10 shares of Toyota Stock just because I liked the company. Most of my investing in the beginning was like this, just picking companies because I liked their services personally.

Four days after buying that 1st Toyota Stock, I saw Netflix stock dip and proceeded to buy 5 shares at $118.25/share. The very next day the shares tanked and were only worth $77.50. Instead of panicking and selling all my stocks, I decided to double down and use dollar cost averaging to hopefully save on some of my losses, so I bought 5 more. Four years later the stock split 7:1 and are now selling at $145.17 a share, that’s($1,016/Share before the split) – it has gone up 938% since I bought it.

So that was awesome right? but what about my other stock picks, like Groupon and Ebay which both tanked for me…? Yes I picked some winners, but I also picked a lot of losers. I tell you this story so you don’t go into investing without a clue like I did. I very rarely ever buy individual companies now, and if I do I consider it almost like play money.

Now all my serious investments go into low cost index funds(ex. VFINX Vanguards S&P 500 Index Fund). This is advised because you’re success is no longer determined by the outcome of one or a few companies. These index funds can comprise of 100’s of companies and provide lower costs since they are typically passively managed, lower risk since they are diversified through multiply companies in a single fund, and more tax efficiency do to there being less trades than an actively managed fund.

I consider myself a very passive investor. I look at my portfolio maybe once a week, and very rarely sell anything. Right now, I have automatic distributions from my bank account into my Roth IRA; mostly putting money into a Vanguard Admiral Fund. I set the automatic distribution to max out my Wife’s IRA and my own IRA for the year, $11,000 between the both of us.

For those who still have a lot of high interest debts, I recommend reading my budgeting post, and also to look at the flowchart below. If you have the extra income, definetly start investing – start with the seven steps outline at the beginning of this post. Do this and your future self will thank-you. I wish you all the best of luck and Godspeed!


Below is a flowchart from the Personal Finance Reddit Community on how you should ideally prioritize your Income Spending:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.